So what's he up to this time? If you've seen the end of the last film in the franchise, "At World's End", you see Sparrow (Johnny Depp) adding a new prize to his never ending list of prizes - the Fountain of Youth. So just as planned, Capt. Jack Sparrow and Capt. Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush) join forces in this film to find this elusive fountain, but on the way find that the pirate Capt. Blackbeard (Ian McShane) and his seductive daughter Angelica (Penelope Cruz) are also after the same thing, which creates complications. Sparrow and Angelica evidently have a history, and he's not sure whether or not she's the love of his life or if she's a con-artist merely using him to get to the fountain. After getting kidnapped by Angelica and forced onto Blackbeard's ship, the Queen Anne's Revenge, Sparrow finds himself on his newest adventure filled with zombie pirates (yes, you read right), mermaids, and a new mismatched crew.
I thought that after watching Depp sway and slur and narrowly escape death several times throughout the past films, I would get tired of the same old situations. But it seems that there's still something newly funny in this character he's so brilliantly created. Does he swing around on ropes? Yes. Does he make funny faces? Yes. Does he narrowly miss being shot at and/or stabbed? Yes. Alright, so there is a lot of the same old stuff. Maybe it's because he's been given a new set of characters to play off of, but I still found myself grinning and enjoying each scene. Sometimes you can unfortunately see the joke coming from a mile away because by now, you feel like you know Capt. Jack Sparrow, but he's still got a few new tricks up his sleeve. I commend Johnny Depp for creating such a solid character that can withstand four movies of the same franchise, and not have the audience nodding off to sleep in boredom by the end of it. I won't spoil it, but he gives you quite a good laugh at the end - let's just say that I give props to the music editor.
Angelica is somewhat of a departure from Elizabeth Swann, though Cruz plays her just as hardheaded and outspoken. I'm not a big fan of Cruz, and her character is admittedly none too exciting. Still, she plays the dark-haired seductress Angelica well, who is quick to know how to get what she wants. Perhaps the perfect match for Sparrow? The chemistry is definitely strong between Cruz and Depp - or maybe it's just because they both seem to have the same taste in eye makeup.
Mermaids, by the way, are not really The Little Mermaid type in this film - rather, they're more like the Sirens of Greek Mythology, the dangerous seductresses that lure sailors to unfortunate ends. An interesting twist.
Ian McShane does a good job of playing Blackbeard. And actually, this film does depart from the other three in that it is the first to include actual historical figures, like Blackbeard, and also King George II and Ferdinand the VI of Spain. Blackbeard's got a few of his own "mystical" tricks to watch out for. But I feel that no enemy of Sparrow's will ever have as great a presence as Barbossa, or at least when he was still an enemy. I remember getting chills when we first heard of the Black Pearl and it's captain that was "so evil, that Hell itself spat him back out" - Geoffrey Rush's portrayal was downright creepy and the rhythm of his dialogue was like a haunting trance. Instead, McShane's Blackbeard is lighter and a bit more comical, which plays off of Depp's Sparrow just fine.
My one great criticism of this film, however, is the introduction of "zombie pirates". Remember how Barbossa's crew was cursed as the undead, who become skeletons in the moonlight? That CG was amazing. Except in this film, we've got a new cursed crew, Blackbeard's crew, who are...zombies. Hold up, aren't zombies, pirates, ninjas, and werewolves all supposed to be in different categories (at least according to Facebook games)? Can you actually mix together two of them? In any case, the "zombie" aspect threw me off, and was not a necessary addition. That's just asking for mockery, come on.
The cinematography was great as usual, though I unfortunately saw it in 3-D, as "Pirates" has fallenprey to Hollywood's great obsession with three-dimensionalism. Leave the 3-D to animation, please. I wouldn't call this particular installment a family film, though the jokes and witty banter are often enough to save it from becoming too dark and creepy. I can see the directors trying to create a few more "Pirates" films, although the charm would probably start to wear off after the fifth or sixth one. After learning that Eric Whitacre, one of my all-time favorite composers, was collaborating with Hans Zimmer on this soundtrack, I was left a bit disappointed with the music. With past epic scores like "At Wit's End", I was expecting more. But then again, there wasn't much in this film that called for brilliant scoring.
Bottom line: go see it if you've enjoyed the franchise so far, but don't expect to have a changing experience.